|
Review
by Kozo: |
Basically a movie of the
week, HK Cinema-style, City of SARS is minor
anthology of tales all set in a city under seige. Taking
place during the famed outbreak of Severe Acute Respiratory
Syndrome, the stories illustrate issues facing HK people
during those troubled times. The stories themselves
aren't really much to write home about, and mine familiarand
even hackneyedthemes. Still, this minor glimpse
into the lives of HK people is welcome enough to moderately
interest.
In story one, a doctor (Patrick
Tam) and a nurse (Kristy Yeung) experience professional
doubt when confronted with SARS. As the hospital ward
begins to fill up and co-workers fall ill to the disease,
the two must come to terms with their chosen professions.
Will they brave the disease, or resign and run away?
Since this is a "hopeful" film, the results
are never in doubt, but the drama portrayed is effective.
Plus Patrick Tam and Kristy Yeung are nice to look at.
Story two involves a self-involved
young woman (Serena Po, formerly of Cookies) who is
sent to a quarantine camp when her apartment complex
comes under suspicion for SARS. While there, she spends
her time trying to contact her jerk-off boyfriend, who
previous to her detainment preferred playing Solitaire
on his PC than spending time with her. Her cell phone
never rings, but luckily there's Henry (Edwin Siu) to
make things better. Probably the nicest guy in the known
universe, Henry spends his SARS days trying to make
life better for everyone else, a message which is neither
subtle or new. Eventually, she recognizes that her current
boyfriend is a heel, but not before her new guy has
to get carted to the hospital. Serena Po is not much
of an actress, and ultimately her story is a bit of
a yawner. This is easily the least interesting of the
three stories, but hey, at least Edwin Siu seems like
a nice guy.
The last story plays like
a comedy, and features Eric Tsang as Boss Hung, a blustery
businessman who gets his comeuppance when SARS punches
a hole in his pocket. With fear of the disease on the
rise, fewer people frequent his restaurants and karaoke
clubs. Since Hung wants his sister (Sharon Chan) to
be taken care of, he decides to off himself in the best
way possible: contract SARS and die a media-hyped death.
The satiric quality of the third story makes it the
most interesting, but Steve Cheng's direction is more
muddled than sharp. When you factor in Eric Tsang's
criminally annoying performance, the third tale seems
like a misfire.
Ultimately, what's best
about City of SARS are its minor insights into
what it was like to live in a city beset by such a swift
and alarming disease. The varying ways in which SARS
is discussed makes for some interesting viewing. The
doctors deal with it directly, the citizens fear its
possible encroachment on their lives, and some people
view it as a big joke until it costs them their businesses.
There are the occasional laughable flourishes (the virus
is seen spreading through the air not unlike the ebola
in Outbreak), but to see the different ways the
disease affected the day-to-day lives of normal people
is both refreshing and undeniably interesting. City
of SARS is probably better viewing for those who
actually weren't in Hong Kong, since those that were
there had to deal with this stuff ad nauseum. Ultimately,
this isn't really a good film, but it's not an entirely
unworthy one, either. (Kozo 2004) |
|