|
Review
by Kozo: |
Meng Kerou (Guey Lun-Mei)
is a seemingly average Taiwan teen who hangs out almost
exclusively with pal Lin Yuezhen (Liang Shu-Hui).
Their lives are filled with the usual stuff: their
high school lives and boys, though the latter seems
to be primarily Yuezhen's domain. Yuezhen holds a
severe torch for Zhang Shihao (Wilson Chen Bo-Lin),
a seventeen year-old swim team member who she simply
cannot approach. Though it's rather silly, Yuezhen
is simply too shy and immature to openly talk to Shihao,
so she uses Kerou as an intermediary. Shihao ends
up thinking that it's Kerou who has a thing for him,
and not Yuezhen, who he writes off as being a fictional
creation on Kerou's part. Yuezhen makes matters worse
by signing a love letter in Kerou's name, and Kerou
ultimately gets fed up enough to hold off on convincing
Shihao of the truth. When Shihao starts to show true
interest in Kerou, this can only lead to trouble.
The
expected and logical plotline of Blue Gate Crossing
could be this: girl and guy fall for one another,
but since the girl's friend secretly likes the guy,
the girl is afraid to fulfill her desire. Right? Wrong.
Though the plot of Blue Gate Crossing sounds
suspiciously like your average John Hughes film, writer-director
Yee Chin-Yen eschews commercial obviousness for a
simpler storyline and complex, recognizable characters.
Kerou's problems do involve the "my friend likes
the guy" issue, and a love triangle does form
between the three teens, but Kerou's target may not
be Shihao. Societal norms dictate who Kerou is and
exactly who she's supposed to like, but if she goes
against that, what exactly does it mean?
Murky descriptions aside,
many other films have contained similiar stories of
sexual awakening, but Yee Chin-Yen manages to find
some refreshing, innocently charming ground on which
to set his drama. The kids are perhaps a bit behind
the times (you wouldn't see the teens in Larry Clark's
Kids acting so unrealistically naive), and
nothing really groundbreaking ever occurs. Still,
the direction is appreciably hands-off and engagingly
matter-of-fact. Events unfold in generous long takes,
with camera setups accurately depicting moments of
intimacy and distance, and dialogue that's spare and
very realistic in its obtuse repetition. Characters
reveal themselves through action more than dialogue,
and though much of what goes on is opaque, the actors
are able to convey myraid layers of emotions. The
teens are deglamorized and realistically portrayed,
and their inner turmoil never overdone. Yee Chin-Yen
could have made this an over-the-top emotion fest,
but his direction is stylish and artful without being
obvious.
If Blue Gate Crossing has any true weakness, it would perhaps be that it's
a little too sweet and innocently played. The high
school world of these teens lacks any sordid realism,
and though some of the situations might merit more
serious emotional damage, that never seens to be a
danger here. At the same time, the growth and change
the characters experience can be subtly compelling.
This is especially true in the case of Zhang Shihao,
whose quiet maturation from boy to man makes him an
exceptionally likable character. Conversely, Lin Yuezhen
seems to be on the slow track to growing up, and her
character's wide-eyed denial of reality makes her
a less likable, though frightfully real character.
Meng Kerou is an even bigger narrative bomb, as her
personal issues have been the curse of many a "sensitive"
film about sexuality. A certain tension is created
by Kerou's sexual confusion, and the result might
feel like a cop-out to some, or a poetic compromise
to others. Its easy to say that Blue Gate Crossing falls short of true significance because it becomes
more slice-of-life than definitively-telling, but
that might be being too critical. Regardless of what
it truly accomplishes, Blue Gate Crossing is
an astoundingly lovely little film. (Kozo 2004) |
|