|
Review
by Kozo: |
Tired of the revenge
grind? Would you like to see director Park Chan-Wook
lighten up? If so, here's your antidote: I'm a
Cyborg, But That's OK. Park goes for a change-up
with his latest flick, which eschews the overtly dark,
intense themes of his vaunted Vengeance Trilogy for
something seemingly more warm and fuzzy. Megahot singer-dancer
Rain headlines the film, but the real star is Lim
Su-Jeong (Lump of Sugar). Lim plays Young-Goon,
an odd young lass whose quirks are so extreme that
she's been committed to an institution. You see, Young-Goon
thinks she's a cyborg, so she talks to the soda machine,
fantasizes about using her cybernetic enhancements
to slaughter the doctors, and generally eschews normal
human activities like, say, eating. Life can be simple
when you design your own reality.
Young-Goon isn't the only
one lacking a few spark plugs; her fellow asylum residents
are also stuck in their own realities. The place is
crowded with an amusing menagerie of unbalanced misfits,
many of whom get generous screentime to demonstrate
their mental maladies. Chief among them is Il-sun
(Rain), a young man who supposedly possesses the power
to steal another person's soul. Even though it makes
absolutely no realistic sense for Il-Sun's "soul theft"
to work, he's able to practice it on his fellow patients,
stealing a variety of their attributes, including
their ping pong abilities, their overdone humility,
and more. Young-Goon takes an interest in Il-Sun because
she wants him to steal her lingering humanity, so
that she'll be able to execute the doctors via her
imaginary bullet-shooting fingers. Il-Sun returns
Young-Goon's interest for more real-world reasons.
Not only does Il-Sun start to show romantic interest
in Young-Goon, but Young-Goon's self-proclaimed cyborg
status starts to become self-destructive. Can Il-Sun
help her before her cyborg fantasies end in her own
death?
I'm a Cyborg, But That's
OK is a rather obtuse experience, especially in
the early going. The film begins like an absurd, Tim
Burton-esque fantasy, with the patients and their
individual problems given affectionate, entertaining
focus. We're introduced to them as people and not
as head cases, and their madness seems like something
to celebrate and enjoy, in a "haha, these delusional
people are funny" sort of way. It's all rather amusing
and enjoyable, but after we receive introduction upon
introduction to the asylum's patients, the parade
of disturbed, but still quite loveable headcases starts
to get tiring. There's only so much a person can take
of the absurd characters and their situations; before
long, the film seems to lose direction. We get that
the patients are loveable and messed up, but we don't
get that the film necessarily has a point. Sure, Lim
Su-Jeong is cute and Rain is charming, but can that
carry a whole film? We say no.
However, the film rights
itself during the second half once Young-goon's eating
issues take greater importance. Young-goon refuses
to eat any real food because in her mind, she's a
cyborg and only requires a good recharge to get back
her mojo. In reality, she's on her way to starvation,
and the concern that Il-Sun shows - and his method
for getting her to start eating again - is creative
and even touching. The film takes some time to get
going, but once Park's main characters begin to connect,
the film becomes much more affecting. For the most
part, Park shows a remarkable handle on his material,
managing not to overdo the quirky or slop on the sentimentality.
There's still plenty of sentiment and quirkiness in
the film, but Park makes it palatable by getting us
to care. He shows obvious affection for his characters,
and easily conveys that to the audience. The actors
help too; Lim Su-Jeong and Rain turn in engaging performances,
managing to create real sympathy for their sometimes
cloying, overly cute characters.
Despite its abundant comedy
and the cuteness, the film possesses dark and even
disturbing portions, too. The audience receives many
flashbacks where we witness the circumstances that
drive the characters to get committed - or sometimes
even voluntarily check in - to the hospital. The
scenes possess an emotional rawness that make them
compelling, and are tough to watch because they portray
the emotional suffering of people we've come to care
about. Hereditary madness, shock therapy, suicide
attempts, vomiting - these things are not warm and
fuzzy, and Park doesn't exactly put a happy face on
all of it. I'm a Cyborg, But That's OK looks
like it'll be a light, romantic comedy, and the warm,
sometimes inviting production design and absurd, deadpan
comic tone bear that out. But there's stuff underneath
the surface that does stick to your guts - that is,
when the burgeoning romance between Rain and Lim Su-Jeong
isn't making your heart skip a beat. Thanks to the
above, plus some clunky existential themes AND some
graphic fantasy sequences where Young-Goon shoots
up the hospital, we can officially declare this to
be true: I'm a Cyborg, But That's OK has something
for everyone.
What it doesn't have, however,
is a completely convincing mixture of elements. The
film is sometimes unfocused and uneven, and doesn't
really earn every last one of its thematic or narrative
conceits. A large part of Cyborg plays like
a fantasy, but clearly, the film takes place in the
real world. As a result, one might expect the film
to go the direction of One Flew Over the Cuckoo's
Nest, i.e. there may be a real-life price to pay
for being out of touch with reality. That never comes
to pass, however, and the film ultimately wheezes
to a protracted ending punctuated by the appearance
of an obviously symbolic rainbow. Happy tidings get
their due, and from an audience standpoint, the warm
and fuzzy feelings do make the film immediately enjoyable.
However, given all the elements in play - and the
cold, hard fact that these misfits are simply unable
to care for themselves - the eventual leaning towards
the positive doesn't exactly ring true.
Still, there's credit owed
here. I'm a Cyborg, But That's OK is a tough
movie to sell, as its mixture of surreal fantasy,
uncomfortable reality, and too-cute characters can
be as alienating as it is enchanting. The whole may
not entirely convince, but Park Chan-Wook makes the
parts exceptionally effective. Park's deadpan comedy
instincts are razor sharp, whether he uses them in
the service of black humor or surreal fantasy, and
many key moments in the film are undeniably felt.
As a director, Park possesses the rare ability to
engage the audience in unexpected ways; his films
are edgy and entertaining, and always go beyond superficial
thrills or laughs for something deeper and more felt. Cyborg is most definitely a change-up, but
it's also a welcome one. Frankly, it's refreshing
to see a director try something new instead of leaning
on the same genres and themes as some suddenly hot
international directors (think Wong Kar-Wai) are wont
to do. I'm a Cyborg, But That's OK may be one
of Park Chan-Wook's weaker efforts, but as another
entry in his hopefully rapidly growing filmography,
it's a fine little film. (Kozo 2007)
|
|