|
Review
by Kozo: |
Notorious on the film-fest
circuit for incurring the wrath of Chinese censors prior
to release, Lost in Beijing gets off to a claustrophobic,
alienating start. This Beijing-set tale of adultery,
chicanery, and assorted human crappiness is told free
of comfy cinema technique, like establishing shots,
static camera, or emotion created through calculated
montage. Basically, the stuff designed to elicit a programmed
audience response is largely missing, replaced here
by a surprisingly funny, dark semblance of reality.
Director Li Yu uses mostly moving camera to tell her
story, taking us directly into her characters' lives
in all their dirty, ugly glory. The result is a film
that can really turn an audience off, as it carries
no positive payoff or uplifting reward. At the same
time, the film manages to be darkly entertaining and
even powerful thanks to a cynical wit and glimpses into
recognizable human ugliness.
Fan Bing-Bing stars as Pingguo,
who works at a massage parlor for Lin (Tony Leung Ka-Fai),
her whoring but otherwise professional boss. Pingguo
is married to window washer Kun (Tong Dawei), a fact
that she keeps secret from her employer, and the two
share a meager existence not unexpected for recent country-to-city
transplants in Beijing. But things change when Lin rapes
Pinguo; he finds her drunk in the massage parlor offices
and proceeds to act on his poorly tamed libido. Kun,
who's washing the windows outside, witnesses the crime,
and is at first incensed. But Kun's anger gives way
to greed; he attempts to blackmail Lin, threatening
to tell the cops if he doesn't give up some cash. Lin
won't bow to Kun's blackmail, but Pingguo's threats
- using her semen-stained clothes as proof - keep her
employed. Once Kun tells Lin's wife (Elaine Kam) of
the situation, she has her own solution: rape Lin's
wife in retaliation for Lin raping his wife. He obliges
- with her consent, naturally - and everyone is now
guilty, save perhaps Pingguo.
Things get even more screwed
when Pingguo discovers that she's pregnant. The baby
could be either Kun's or Lin's, and Pingguo is loath
to keep it given the circumstances. However, Kun uses
the pregnancy as another opportunity for blackmail.
This time it works, because Lin and his wife have never
been able to conceive, and Lin desperately wants a child.
The two men strike a cynical, damning bargain, with
Lin getting the unborn child and Kun getting the money.
But that's just the beginning for this ménage-a-quatre,
as each jockeys for what they want, usually disregarding
morality or common decency along the way. Lin wants
the child, but with the comely Pingguo around, he may
want something else. Mrs. Lin also wants the child,
but she absolutely does not want Lin to spend more time
with the younger and more attractive Pingguo. Kun wants
the money, but if the child does turn out to be his,
his ego won't allow him to simply let go. The lone holdout
for moral murkiness is Pingguo, who's pulled in multiple
directions. Now out of control, the situation spins
in a sometimes darkly humorous and ultimately inescapable
direction.
The title Lost in Beijing implies a sort of socio-cultural significance, though
it's arguable if the film truly achieves that. Besides
the characters' obvious economic and social differences,
Li Yu sometimes resorts to shaky montages set on the
streets of Beijing, highlighting the varying class strata
in passing. Still, what goes on with the main characters
is more about their familiar and flawed personalities
than some sort of grand thematic tale of class difference.
This is a story that could conceivably take place anywhere,
as the human ugliness on display seems very universal.
The characters are given many chances to do honorable
things, but they frequently deny those chances, opting
for self-gratification or material wealth over common
decency. What's surprising is how each character manages
to shift sympathy as the film progresses. Lin is a seeming
rat bastard when it comes to women, but his attitudes
towards family and money are surprisingly decent. Conversely,
Kun's pragmatism gives way to a despicable greed, though
he manages to show a heart when not blinded by ego or
jealousy. Lost in Beijing's characters are so
pathetic that they end up feeling very real, earning
empathy while also repelling us.
Li Yu's handheld camera adds
to the immediacy and seeming reality of the film, frequently
finding humor that's both funny and quite sad. Tony
Leung Ka-Fai overacts admirably as Lin, managing to
be both likable and despicable, while Tong Dawei and
Elaine Kam portray their reprehensible, yet sometimes
pathetic and pitiable characters with admirable abandon.
The film belongs to Fan Bing-Bing, however, who ditches
her usual flower vase image with a gutsy performance
as the vulnerable, yet resolute Pingguo. The situations
in Lost in Beijing are sometimes exaggerated,
but the storytelling, cinematography and performances
keep the film grounded, such that it feels like it could
actually happen. Li Yu convinces us of the reality of
the situation, giving the film its status as both a
well-observed drama and a darkly entertaining comedy
of human crappiness. The circumstances may not be so
extreme, but you can probably see people behaving like
this in real life. These characters could be lost almost
anywhere, and not just in Beijing. (Kozo, Reviewed at the Hong Kong Asian Film Festival, 2007) |
|