|
Review by
Calvin
McMillin: |
Based
on the work of author Shuhei Jujisawa, The Twilight
Samurai tells the story of one Seibei Iguchi (Hiroyuki
Sanada), a widower with two daughters and a senile
old mother, all of whom must survive on what little
salary Seibei receives as a low-level samurai. Every
day, once his duties are complete, Seibei rushes home
to see to his family and begin work on his sideline
job in order to make ends meet. Although his coworkers
often ask him to go out drinking with them, his always
refuses. Eventually, this pattern of bolting home
as night falls earns him the nickname of "Twilight
Seibei" among his colleagues.
Things start to pick
up when Tomonojo Iinuma (Mitsuru Fukikoshi), one of
Seibei's closest friends re-enters his life. Iinuma
tells him of the fate of his sister, Tomoe (Rie Miyazawa),
who has just recently divorced her abusive husband
Toyotaro Kouda (Ren Osugi) and taken up residence
with Iinuma. Soon enough, Tomoe pays a visit to Seibei,
and the two catch up on old times. Things seem to
be getting off to a good start for both Tomoe and
Seibei, but when Toyotaro shows up at Iinuma's home
to lay claim to his ex-wife, Seibei must intervene,
eventually getting himself involved in a duel with
the drunken samurai. With nothing but a wooden sword,
Seibei faces Toyotaro at the appointed time, and in
a very entertaining scene, bests the man in one-on-one
combat. In the succeeding days, Tomoe begins visiting
Seibei more often, tending to the chores, playing
with the children, and generally bringing an overwhelming
sense of happiness and warmth to the Iguchi household.
Considering how well
things are going, the natural next step for Tomoe
and Seibei, both of whom share a genuine affection
for one another, would be for the two of them to get
married, right? However, while there is nothing more
Seibei would like than to make Tomoe his wife, he
fears that his lowly status would be far too much
for her to bear in the long run. Making matters worse,
the clan is undergoing some intense internal drama
that may end up having some major consequences for
Seibei. Once his superiors learn of his sword-fighting
abilities, they order him to kill the "rebel"
Zenemon Yoga, who is a master swordsman in his own
right. Clearly, Seibei's death would prevent any chance
for a "happily ever after" ending with Tomoe.
Will he survive? And will Tomoe, who has received
numerous proposals, even be available if he does?
What is remarkable about Twilight Samurai is that it is the type of
samurai film that does not rely on swordfights or
bold displays of heroism to win over its audience.
Instead, the film's focus is on character, Seibei's
in particular. The heart and soul of the film is Seibei's
relationship with his loved ones, and Hiroyuki Sanada
brings a sense of dignity, honor, and humanity to
the role. Rather than gear us up for swordfights that
would provide viewers with vicarious thrills, Twilight
Samurai gives us a compelling depiction of Seibei's
home life, a narrative decision that makes the world
of the samurai feel more threatening, since one clan
order or one unnecessary duel could end Seibei's life,
thus impacting the lives of the people he cares about.
By adding this level of danger, Twilight Samurai proves to be marvelous change of pace from films in
which the protagonist has absolutely nothing to lose
and the duels are meant to provide nothing more than
sword-slashing thrills.
This focus on characterization
and realism is perhaps best illustrated in the film's
climax. Seibei's duel with Zenemon Yoga begins with
a conversation, one that questions the samurai code
in a way that most chambara films do not. This dialogue
soon erupts into a close-quarters, claustrophobic
duel, one in which the audience becomes increasingly
unsure of whether Seibei will survive. Reminiscent
of Clint Eastwood's Unforgiven, Yamada's film
marks the end of an era. It's a deconstruction of
the genre, one that mocks the hypocrisy of the samurai
code, yet at the same time, through the character
of Seibei, it is also a celebration of the ideals
of that very same code, as it gives a wonderfully
humane rendering of one honest man struggling to survive
in a chaotic world.
Helping the story along
is actress Rie Miyazawa, who makes great use of her
seemingly limited screen time. Tomoe's positive influence
on Seibei's life is not merely a case of a subservient
female coming in to take care of "women's work,"
but instead, her role runs far deeper than that. Tomoe's
warmth, compassion, and genuine affection for Seibei
and his family only increases the sense that she is
the missing element in the Iguchi home. Her relationship
with Seibei is well-developed and adds an ample amount
of poignancy to the would-be couple's possibly final
conversation towards the film's ending.
Twilight Samurai may be somewhat low key, even simple, in terms of
execution, but it is still deserving of every honor
it has been awarded. In giving us such a sincere,
honest protagonist in Seibei, the film shows how his
personal code is out of step with the times, critiquing
an era in which self-interest and self-preservation
- not honor and compassion - are of utmost importance
to those in power. Yet it also delivers romance, and
yes, even a couple of good swordfights to keep us
glued to our seats. Well-executed, surprisingly realistic,
and infinitely compelling, Yoji Yamada's Twilight
Samurai is nothing less than a modern classic.
(Calvin McMillin, 2005) |
|